CPI Asia

Home Dr. Lim Teck Ghee Utusan Malaysia: Messenger of hate and spite on religion and race
Utusan Malaysia: Messenger of hate and spite on religion and race Print E-mail
CPI Writings
Written by Dr Lim Teck Ghee   
Tuesday, 15 December 2009 21:27
Share Link: Share Link: Bookmark Google Yahoo MyWeb Del.icio.us Digg Facebook Myspace Reddit Ma.gnolia Technorati Stumble Upon

Sitting today in a small group international meeting on the subject of the linkages between religion and development being held in Phnom Penh, I am engaged in deep discussion on how to build inter-faith synergies that can effectively address the many pressing challenges of the region.

The group of 15 participants from different faiths and religions (I am possibly the sole atheist participant) includes three Muslim activist colleagues. They are the country director of Muslim Aid from Bangladesh; a Muhammadiyah senior lecturer from the State Institute for Islamic Studies in Walinsongo Semarang, Indonesia; and the executive director of a Muslim-based organization Ummah Fi Salam based in Mindanao that has been working on an interfaith programme called ‘Building Darusalam’ or ‘peace communities’.

Present also is a Muslim senior lecturer from the National University of Singapore who is actively involved with giving voice to professional Muslim women in Singapore.

Our two-day workshop is part of the research programme underway at Georgetown University’s Berkley Center for Religion, Peace and World Affairs, and the World Faiths Development Dialogue which has to date covered North America, the Middle East, Europe and Africa, and Latin America. More information is available on the Berkley Center website: http://berkleycenter.georgetown.edu

What I (and others from the non-Muslim faiths) have gotten from our discussions with these Muslim colleagues is not only of their strong conviction in their religion as a religion of compassion, peace and justice; but also of their view of the need for Muslims to stand up and speak out against disrespect, intolerance or injustice, especially in instances when these actions are carried out in the name of the religion against people of other religions and faiths.

As I return to my laptop to review the latest news from the Utusan Malaysia on developments on race and religion in the country, the contrast between the noble values and reasoned and rational statements of my Muslim colleagues here and the ‘Islamic supremacy’ mindset and irrational and provocative ranting of the newspaper editors makes me wonder what version of Islam the Utusan Malaysia is promoting.

The contrast between these Muslim colleagues committed to values of justice, freedom, equality and peace that are common to all religions and faiths, and the Utusan proponents of a racist and religiously warped social order for Malaysia could not be more striking.

In Cambodia for the workshop, these Muslim advocates for inter-faith understanding and reconciliation come from poorer and less developed societies that have much less in the way of material achievement and socio-economic goods. Yet their respect, lack of envy, compassion and positive attitudes towards other religions shines through in their writings, speeches and actions.

In contrast, our Utusan Malaysia and their compatriots of similar ideology are affluent, well educated and come from the most prosperous and powerful Muslim society in the region. From them what we get are messages of hate, spite, narrow-mindedness and intolerance towards the non-Muslim and non-Malay communities in the country. How sad!

See articles by Utusan Malaysia editors – English version translated by Utusan Online.

Excerpts:

 

“Are the Muslims there [in the developed countries] accorded the same so-called freedom enjoyed by others and behave disrespectfully as [Nga] Kor Ming does in this country? So what is the most logical justification for Kor Ming in kicking up the issue which is contradictive to the spirit of the Constitution? If the spirit of the Constitution is to be taken literally, the government has the right not to fork out even a single cent of allocation for other religion. However, out of respect and generosity, the government is kind enough to give out millions of ringgit in allocation for the houses of worship of other religions. But such benevolence is seen by the likes of Kor Ming with blind eyes.”

 

Do not fool around with Islam
(Utusan news editor Noraini Abd. Razak, Dec 11)

 

 

“In Malaysia, everyone strives to protect the rights and interests of their respective races, but not to the extent of hurting the feelings of other races. When they are leaders who use racial issues for their political interests, then the differences that have been in existence will be obvious. Political leaders who accuse their rival as being racist and raise sensitive issues, are actually racists themselves. Questioning the Malay supremacy, for example, is racist and intent to create animosity.”

 

What is not racist?
(Utusan editor Aznan Bakar, Dec 10)

 

 

“Failure in handling such issue [stirring racial sentiments] will spark racial extremism. Many of the Malays are keeping silent. But that does not mean they agree. A time will come when they are running out of patient, the outcome of which will bring disaster to the country. Awang is mixing around with the Malay at the grassroot involving all parties and can feel their overwhelming sentiment. So do not take for granted the patience and generosity of the Malays. Does the DAP leaders like Kulasegaran and Kor Ming want to be responsible when the explosion come?”

 

Is Malaysia heading towards a republic?
(Awang Selamat, Dec 13)

 

Malaysians are deprived of a free media when industry practitioners become too close to the ruling parties and their newspapers are owned by these parties and their cronies.

Journalists like The Star’s Joceline Tan clinch top awards at the inaugural Umno Media Appreciation Night for her writings, and her RM5,000 and notebook prize presented by no less than the Umno president Najib Razak himself. Whereas independent news portals are branded ‘racist’ by the likes of Utusan’s infamous Awang Selamat.

Without a free media, distortions like that purveyed by Utusan news editor Noraini Abd. Razak, who refers to the great ‘benevolence’ of the federal government in funding other religions, is left unchallenged.

But according to external sources, “The federal government, allocated RM428 million to build Islamic places of worship, and RM8.1 million to build Christian, Buddhist, Hindu, and other places of worship for minority religious groups between 2005 and 2008.”

Contrast this with the Selangor state government under Pakatan which in January 2009 alone allocated RM6 million for non-Muslim places of worship.

PAS’s embattled Perak Menteri Besar Nizar Jamaluddin rebutted Utusan saying that the Umno Malays were presently attempting to distort all statements and actions taken by the non-Malay politicians in the Pakatan Rakyat, in order to create a false impression that they were ‘anti-Malay’. “They are doing this everywhere and trying to get the Malays to believe them”.

Now I’ve only just read of the threat to use the ISA on DAP state representative Nga Kor Ming for questioning the lack of government resources to other religious houses of worship between the years 2000 and 2008, compared to the RM748.26mil spent on the construction of 611 mosques.

The thought then occurs to me that if the situation was reversed in Malaysia and there was a non-Muslim majority or if another religion was the religion of the Federation, surely these same people would be concerned about the extent to which the state was practicing religious equality and the extent of bias and prejudice that may be inherent in official policies against the Muslims.

The Utusan Malaysia writings highlighed above have little in common with the Islamic values and norms of the great majority of the Muslim community in the country.

There was a phrase used by one of my fellow participants earlier today on the need to reach out to “the religious hardliners however much they may appear to be beyond the pale”. Since non-Muslims cannot reach out to them, it is important that more rational thinking Malaysian Muslims do this and not sit by idly while their co-religionists propagate their messages of fear and hate.
Comments (21)
  • Jong  - Don't shame ISLAM!

    It's not about religion or being religious but good human qualities that is so lacking in all of them.

    Shame on you despicable three - Noraini Abd Razak, Aznan Bakar and Awang Selamat! Do not shame the religion.

  • StraightTalking  - Malaysia is not for Malaysians

    I've said this and I'll say it again. Until and unless the Malays become Malaysians, the nons can continue to live here in Malaysia for another million years but they will still be regarded pendatangs.

    Given half the chance, the Malays will want to officially change the name Malaysia to Tanah Melayu.

    The only people in Malaysia who do not think like a Malaysian are the Malays. Not all of course, but most of them.

    Dr. Lim, do you agree with my views?

    I might sound like an anti-Malay, but I'm not. I'm merely basing my opinion on what I see, hear, and read and making an honest and neutral assessment.

  • layman

    what do we expect? after years of brain washing n propaganda,just waiting for the bubble to burst n chaos will lured...

  • JimK  - Islam in power.

    It does appear that the more prominent Islam is in a society the less tolerant it is of others. Only in positions of weakness does it preach tolerance and understanding. It is good tactics.

  • shuib  - Dr Lim - you are right. 1Melayu Islam

    yes, we Malays and Muslims that are truly Malaysians must speak out against Utusan. They want the Malays to hate others esp Chinese and Indians. Pandai main isu isu perkauman. UMNO leadership use Utusan before but now UM outside Najib's control.Their tactic - 1 Melayu Islam, bukan 1Malaysia.

  • Mavericko  - Utusan umNO

    Utusan editors and writers are no different than whores. Probably they dont understand the meaning of it!

  • John  - Islam at its strongest

    I agree Islam in Malaysia is at its strongest now in fact for a good number of years. The stronger they are the more hegemonic they become and more intolerant as well of other faiths and people. Building of temples within council guidelines also they protest and to extent of dragging a cow head to slight certain communities.
    Even the asking in Parliament of why the allocation for Islam is so much more than for other faiths drew howls of protests and even police reports. I thought such behavior is only found in Saudi Arabia. The situation in Malaysia is like a time bomb and we feel Utusan and BH do contribute to the situation.

  • John

    Non muslims pay the most taxes in this country in the words of TDM. But when they ask for more allocation for their houses of worship they get crumbs and harsh words from some editors of certain MSM. They non muslims are even threatened with violence and race riots if they enquired any further.
    It's no fun living in this kind of country and definitely not worth paying the tax we worked so hard for.

  • charleskiwi  - charleskiwi

    There is no end for these UMNO journalists and it will keep happening again and again.
    The only solution is to vote UMNO out in the next GE and have these bastards
    locked up in Taiping jail. Don't forget the first to be indicted should be pariah Mahathir !
    He started everything that is wrong to day and the only solution is to vote UMNO out of this system and have a new government in its place. But not Anwar for sure ! He was part and parcel of UMNO, he is in the opposition today because he was not invited back into UMNO. He saw all the things the way pariah Mahathir did and that was why he got promoted to be the deputy P.M. and when he could not wait to become the P.M. he tried to get rid of the dictator.
    As a result he is where he is to day and non of the present UMNO goons (these goons too have wishes to become the P.M.themselves) would have him back in UMNO. Less man more share !
    Even though he waited a few years after he came out from jail to be invited back to lead UMNO. Only when the invitation did not come, he started the opposition, hoping that might make him the P.M...So don't forget there are lots of good leaders and most of all colour blind, out there with the opposition but not lusty Anwar or always barking like a dog LKS.

  • rashid  - Message to Malay Muslims

    What has happened to us Malay Muslims is worse than what has happened to non-Muslims.

    We have been oppressed and poisoned by our political and religious leaders. So much we lose our own identity and good character. All in name of upliftment of Islam and Malays. Cannot joget, cannot wear modern clothes. Cannot do yoga. Must have girls and women covered up in tudung in hot weather so that many have head skin disease. Alos must be jealous and suspicious of other race and religion.

    No wonder young Malays give up. So much hate, hypocrisy.

    What has happened to our happy bangsa. I am 85 years now. I regret I have lived so long to see my people suffer in the name of ketuanan melayu and islam.

Write comment
Your Contact Details:
Comment:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img]   
Security
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.